Differences in Defining Science: Even Scientists Do Not Agree on What Science Is
A recent study points to fundamental disagreements among scientists themselves about the definition of science and how it is practiced, disagreements that exceed those found among the general public. The study explains that scientists do not fully agree on the nature of science or its goals, raising questions about the impact of these disagreements on scientific research and the public’s understanding of it.
Differences Between Scientists and the Public in Understanding Science
A research team led by Marina Dubova, the researcher who conducted the study during her time at the Santa Fe Institute, examined the views of 91 scientists and 99 members of the public. The study focused on evaluating 18 different descriptions of “science,” drawn from multiple historical perspectives, including the view of science as a search for truth and as a process similar to detective investigations.
The study found that scientists all agree on the importance of curiosity, exploration, and solving puzzles at the heart of science, but they differed on many other points. While some scientists see science as a path to discovering objective and fixed truths, others emphasize the role of imagination, innovation, and personal judgment in scientific research.
Scientists also differed over the following question: does scientific progress depend mainly on following strict standard procedures, or on adaptation and innovation when facing new challenges? These differences may reflect personal experiences and each researcher’s working style, just as chefs have different philosophies for preparing food.
How Does the Public See Science?
By contrast, the public holds more consistent ideas about science, viewing it as a reliable means of obtaining objective facts, while tending to downplay the uncertainty and creativity that accompany scientific research.
The public appears to adopt a view closer to that expressed by physicists and biologists, perhaps because of the influence of educational curricula that focus on these disciplines more than on the social sciences. This difference in perspective partly explains why people sometimes struggle to accept changing scientific results or the complexities that accompany research.
The Impact of the Disagreement on Scientific Research and Society
These differences in understanding science are significant because they may affect:
- The nature of the questions scientists choose to study.
- How the public evaluates scientific results.
- The level of public trust in science, especially when results sometimes change.
Our differing understanding of science can lead to public frustration when scientists do not provide definitive answers or when scientific communities update their conclusions based on new evidence.
Future Challenges: Artificial Intelligence and Science
The study also reveals future challenges in the science of discovery, especially with the expanding role of Artificial Intelligence (Artificial Intelligence) in scientific research. Dubova suggests that AI systems may reinforce a specific model of how science “should” work, which could limit the diversity of research methods and weaken opportunities for innovation and adaptation.
As AI technologies advance, we may need deeper reflection on how to integrate machines into the scientific process without neglecting the importance of different research methods and creative thinking.
Final Notes
This study highlights that we should not take the traditional understanding of science for granted. Science is not only a system of knowledge that is followed automatically; it is also a set of practices that includes creative thinking and personal decisions.
Dubova also stresses the need to continue asking questions and cultivating curiosity to determine what science means to each of us, and how this understanding can shape future research and innovation.
Source: Royal Society Open Science
Discover more from Mohdbali
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.




